Which Edition

Herman Melville

Moby-Dick

Pick what matters most to you

Compare all 5
Cover of Moby-Dick, translated by Penguin Classics
Best for most

Penguin Classics · 2003

Moby-Dick rewards a little help — the whaling chapters and the Biblical and Shakespearean echoes go by fast. Penguin's edition gives you exactly enough: Andrew Delbanco's fine introduction, Tom Quirk's clear notes, and a clean, affordable text. Not so much apparatus that it gets in the way. This is where I'd start.

Cover of Moby-Dick, translated by Norton Critical (3rd ed.)
Best for students

Norton Critical (3rd ed.) · 2017

The student's Moby-Dick. The reliable text, plus illustrations, whaling background, and forty-odd reviews and essays spanning three centuries. If you're studying the novel, or want the whole conversation around it, this is the one. More than a casual reader needs, and priced accordingly.

Cover of Moby-Dick, translated by Longman (Bryant & Springer)
Most annotated

Longman (Bryant & Springer) · 2006

The most annotated Moby-Dick in print. Bryant and Springer pack the margins with explanation, and — unusually — flag the passages Melville and his British publisher revised, so you watch the book change under your eyes. Fascinating if you love the textual history; expensive, and more than most first readers want.

Cover of Moby-Dick, translated by Penguin Deluxe
Most beautiful

Penguin Deluxe · 2009

The Penguin Deluxe edition — Tony Millionaire's cover, deckle edges, Nathaniel Philbrick's introduction. The same readable text as the standard Penguin, dressed up. The one to buy if you want Moby-Dick as an object on the shelf.

Herman MelvilleMoby-Dicktr. Free (public domain)
Free

Free (public domain) · 1851

Moby-Dick is out of copyright, so the full text is free — Project Gutenberg, Standard Ebooks, and others. No notes to catch the allusions, which this book really does benefit from, but if you just want to start, it costs nothing.

See the full comparisonCompare all 5 editions side by side — translator, introduction, notes, and format.

Which Edition earns a small commission from purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you — it never changes our picks.